Father Bartlett is the local priest of Kingston Falls.
Bartlett is seen at the beginning of the story when Billy is seen running to work with his dog, Barney, and waves to him and says hello. He later appears when attempting to send letters down a mailbox. However, the letters spat back out, courtesy of the Mailbox Gremlin that was hiding inside. Mr. Anderson then arrived greeting Father Bartlett and attempted to mail a letter and was attacked by the gremlin before Father Bartlett could warn him.
- In a deleted scene, Billy meets Bartlett outside of the church exist, where they have a brief conversation.